Connect with Douglas Mackay
Douglas Mackay
Soccer Gear Reviewer at Upper 90 Football
Douglas Mackay is a former semi-professional player in the Eastern Premier Soccer League (EPSL) with over 20 years of experience on the pitch. His deep understanding of the game—shaped by years of training, matches, and gear experimentation—naturally evolved into a passion for reviewing soccer cleats. For the past three years, Doug has built a loyal following as the voice behind Upper 90 Football, where he delivers in-depth, honest cleat reviews trusted by players of all levels. His focus is on performance, comfort, and value—helping athletes find the perfect boots for their playing style. You can follow Upper 90 Football on Instagram, YouTube, TikTok, and more for the latest from Doug.
Articles by Douglas Mackay
Different Soccer Formations to Know: Including the Powerful 4-3-3
Soccer isn’t just a game of skill; it’s one of strategy, with formations at the heart of it. Understanding the different soccer formations is essential for any new fan or budding coach, or existing fans in need of a refresher. All soccer formations balance attack and defense, playing to the strengths and styles of the team. So what are the different formations in soccer? From the widely used 4-3-3 to lesser-known formations, this guide will tell you everything you need to know. 4-3-3 Soccer Formation Image Credit: Wikimedia Commons Let’s begin with the 4-3-3 - arguably the most common soccer formation. The 4-3-3 formation features: Four defenders Three central midfielders Three forwards The 4-3-3 formation promotes width, allowing for fast-paced attacks and fluid gameplay between defense and offense. It’s a formation best suited to teams that like to control possession and apply pressure high up the pitch. Tactical Advantages This formation is designed for attacking play and pressing: High press - Allows the team to win the ball back quickly in their opponent’s half. Width in attack - Wingers force the opposition defense to spread out, creating space for central players. Midfield balance - The three players in midfield support both attack and defense. Potential Limitations Despite its strengths, the 4-4-3 comes with risks: Vulnerable to counter-attacks - There’s a risk of interception if fullbacks push up. Too many midfielders - If a team has four or five midfielders, it can be difficult to maintain control. Needs high fitness levels - The formation relies on high energy levels, especially wingers and fullbacks, making strong fitness a must. Teams That Made It Famous Barcelona is one of the teams best known for using the 4-3-3 as part of their tiki-taka style of play. More recently, Liverpool FC have used it in their style of play, while the U.S. Men’s National Team has also used it effectively in recent years. 4-4-2 Soccer Formation Image Credit: Wikimedia Commons The 4-4-2 formation is a more traditional setup that uses: Four defenders Four midfielders Two forwards This style provides simplicity and balance, and is popular at all levels of the game. It’s also an easy formation to coach, and a good formation for new players to get used to. Tactical Advantages 4-4-2 is a strong formation that provides attack and defense as needed. Advantages include: Solid shape - The two rows of four offer a stable defense and positional discipline. Dual strikers - Using two forwards helps maintain a constant attacking threat, and additional support as needed. Wide support - Wingers provide help at both ends of the pitch. Potential Limitations As with any formation, the 4-4-2 style of play also comes with some limitations, including: Too many midfielders - Like the 4-4-3 formation, this can mean players can be outnumbered by teams playing three in the center. Limited creativity - This style relies on crosses and long balls, which can make gameplay slow. Predictable style of play - This formation is easily read and understood, which means it can be countered by more modern tactical setups. Teams That Made It Famous Manchester United dominated the Premier League with the 4-4-2 formation in their 90s glory days, when players like David Beckham, Ryan Giggs and Eric Cantona were key figures. In MLS, LA Galaxy have also used the 4-4-2 successfully during many championships. 4-2-3-1 Soccer Formation Image Credit: Wikimedia Commons Next up is the 4-2-3-1 formation, which features: Four defenders Two defensive midfielders Three attacking midfielders One striker It’s a formation that allows for creativity while supporting defense, and is a more modern formation used by many of today’s clubs. Tactical Advantages There are several benefits that come with the modern 4-2-3-1 formation, including: Defensive cover - The two defensive midfielders provide a solid line of defense in front of the back line. Creativity - The offensive/attacking midfielder (typically No.10) can call the shots behind the striker. Flexibility - The formation can easily shift to a 4-3-3 or 4-4-1 during play. Potential Limitations The limitations of the 4-2-3-1 include: Forward left in isolation - The striker risks being cut off unless play is linked up well. Reliant on midfield - The creative element of the game rests heavily on the offensive midfielder’s shoulders. Wide vulnerabilities - Winners have to focus on defense as well as attack. Teams That Made It Famous Germany won the 2014 World Cup (which took place in Brazil) using the 4-2-3-1 formation. Meanwhile, in the U.S., the formation tends to be used by the Portland Timbers and the Seattle Sounders, bringing them success in MLS games. 3-5-2 Soccer Formation Image Credit: Wikimedia Commons This type of formation includes: Three central defenders Five midfielders (often with wing-backs) Two forwards/strikers This style of play is perfect for dominating in the midfield, while retaining a solid backline and allowing for two up top. It allows for both challenging and defensive play where needed. Tactical Advantages Some of the key advantages of the 3-5-2 formation include: Central dominance - With numbers in the midfield, there is greater control over possession and the pace of the game. Wing-back involvement - Allows for width without sacrificing numbers in the midfield. Dual-threat - Allows for two forwards to challenge defenders constantly. Potential Limitations Among the limitations of the 3-5-2 formation are: Pressure on wing-backs - Requires players to have high stamina and more awareness, putting pressure on that part of the team. Defensive vulnerabilities - Gaps in defense can happen if wing-backs are caught too high, making wide attacks possible. Discipline - Mistakes in transitions can lead to overloads. Teams That Made It Famous Both Juventus and Chelsea adopted the 3-5-2 formation when it was brought in under manager Antonio Conte. In the U.S., Nashville SC has used this style of play to help maximize its strength in the midfield. 3-4-3 Soccer Formation Image Credit: Wikimedia Commons A popular formation for teams with strong strikers looking to put away goals. With a strong focus on attack, the 3-4-3 formation uses: Three center-backs Four midfielders (with wing-backs) Three forwards It’s an ideal formation for teams looking to control the end third and apply aggressive pressure. Tactical Advantages This is an exciting style of play that brings several advantages to teams, including: Constant pressure - The front three players press high, which can lead to defensive errors and allow goals to be scored. Versatility in the midfield - Allows the team to adapt to different in-game shapes. Offensive overload - Helps create superiority in wide areas and central zones, depending on positioning. Potential Limitations Such a high-powered formation comes with some obvious risks, particularly in defense. The main limitations include: Defensively risky - The three back players can be exposed by wide counters. Coaching complexity - A coach needs to have excellent tactical discipline and communication to make this formation work. Risk of fatigue - Wing-backs must cover long distances throughout the game, making high stamina levels a must for these players. Teams That Made It Famous Chelsea is one of the best-known teams for using the 3-4-3 formation, and it featured regularly in their 2016-2017 season, which saw them win the Premier League. It has also been used by Atlanta United to provide creative attacking options. 4-1-4-1 Soccer Formation Image Credit: Wikimedia Commons The 4-1-4-1 is another modern formation that includes: Four defenders One holding midfielder Four midfielders in front One forward/striker The 4-1-4-1 formation can help allow for midfield control while being relatively compact in defense. It suits teams that have some strong strikers in the line-up. Tactical Advantages Some of the main advantages of the 4-1-4-1 formation include: Strong defensive turns - The holding midfielder can survey the back line to influence play. Flexibility in the midfield - Can help make an easy switch between attacking and defensive setups. Controlled pressing - Can ensure organized pressure on the ball to bring some positive results. Potential Limitations Among the limitations of this type of formation are: Forward left alone - The striker can be isolated and left without adequate support when they get the ball. Gaps in the central line - Requires careful coordination to ensure it isn’t bypassed. Teams That Made It Famous Manchester City, under Pep Guardiola, regularly uses variations of the 4-1-4-1, and has had a lot of success in the Premier League in recent years. Meanwhile, New York City FC have used it when controlling possession during certain matches. Other Soccer Formations While the formations listed above are the best-known in the game, there are other formations used by a variety of teams, helping to mix up play and find success. 3-2-4-1 Formation: A bold setup that focuses on high-pressing wing-backs and an attacking overload. This is a variation often used by Manchester City in the English Premier League. 4-2-2-2 Formation: Allows for a narrow, vertical approach that’s ideal for teams with strong central players. 3-4-1-2 Formation: A hybrid shape that not only allows for a solid defense, but also allows for an attacking playmaker behind the two strikers. 4-3-2-1 Formation: Also known as the ‘Christmas Tree’ due to its shape, it focuses on central creativity, with controlled build-up. While some teams prefer to stick to one formation the majority of the time, switching between formations provides flexibility and allows teams to adapt their style of play according to their opponents. Soccer Formations FAQ’s Getting to grips with different formations can help you understand the different types of gameplay, adding excitement and helping you think about soccer more strategically. Some common questions around soccer formations include: 1. What is the best formation in soccer? No single formation is considered ‘the best’ formation. Successful formations depend on the team’s strengths, the tactics used by the opposition, and the game context. Effective coaches will adjust formations depending on what’s happening in the game and the types of players available. This means if players get sent off or are injured, formations can be easily adapted as needed. 2. Why is 4-3-3 so popular? The 4-3-3 formation is popular because it has a balance of defense, midfield and attack. This makes it a strong formation for pressing, possession and quick transitions between players. It’s best suited to teams with strong wingers and dynamic full-backs. 3. Why is 4-2-3-1 so popular The 4-2-3-1 helps provide a solid defensive foundation thanks to two holding midfielders, while also leaving more creative players to focus on attack. It’s a versatile style of play that makes it a very popular formation in modern soccer. 4. How do teams choose the right formation? Choosing the right formation depends on several factors - including player strengths, opponent styles, tactical knowledge and match context. Coaches will usually have to adjust formations to fit in with different circumstances such as injuries, player fitness, home vs. away games or what they want to achieve during a certain point of the game. 5. Can teams change formation during a game? Yes, formation changes are normal during a game. Coaches may need to switch formations according to how many goals have been scored, number of red cards and if there’s a mismatch with the opponent’s style of play. Strong players are trained to adapt to these changes, allowing them to easily switch between formations as needed. 6. What’s the difference between formations with three and four defenders? Formations using three defenders will usually use wing-backs to help expand the width and provide more defensive coverage, whereas formations with four defenders will mainly rely on full-backs. Three-at-the-back defensive systems allow for more control in the midfield, while four-man defense is used to encourage stability, and will be familiar to most players. Understanding the different soccer formations can give you a greater insight into the game and how different teams interact with each other. When watching soccer, you’ll now know what to look for and will soon be able to recognize different styles of play. For all your soccer needs, check out our full selection of soccer apparel at ProSoccer.com.
Read more2025 Best Soccer Cleats by Field Position
Finding the best soccer cleats depends on multiple factors, including playing surface, format and your position on the field. Choosing the right cleats for your position can elevate performance levels and provide additional features to optimize specific gameplay elements. From defenders to strikers, this guide has the information you need to find the best soccer cleats by field position in 2025. Best Soccer Cleats for Defenders Nike Tiempo Legend 10 Elite FG ‘Is the latest Nike Tiempo the greatest? Packed with new features & more sustainable materials, this shoe is the stuff of legend.' Fit: True to size Playing surface options: Firm ground, artificial grass Pros: Flytouch engineered leather for unbeatable comfort Super light Recycled materials Central lacing enhances stability Better in wet conditions than previous versions Cons: Price Not ideal for wide feet The launch of the Nike Tiempo Legend 10 Elite FG was hotly anticipated. This shoe is a step into the unknown for Nike thanks to the introduction of sustainable materials, notably Flytouch engineered leather. The best soccer cleats for defenders need secure fit and stability, and the Nike Tiempo delivers. The best bits are the fit, tight control on different surfaces, unrivaled fresh-from-the-box softness and sustainability. I personally love the new look, fit and style of these soccer cleats, which build on the success and reputation of the Tiempo range but also represent an exciting evolution. The downsides for me are the cost, which is relatively high, and the lack of protection. Adidas Copa Pure 3 Elite FG ‘One of the most comfortable boots on the market, but is it worth the money when compared to similar models? Perhaps not…’ Fit: Runs long Playing surface options: Firm ground, artificial grass Pros: Fusionskin upper for comfort Additional Comfort Frame plate support Very responsive Enhanced padding Stretch Cons: Runs long Lockdown is not as good as others More expensive than others with similar features Adidas is known for eye-catching soccer cleats, but it’s also a force for innovation. The goal for the Copa 3 Pure Elite FG is to stand out in the leather soccer shoe crowd. Does it do this? I’m not sure. Here’s why….. The good points are the much-loved aesthetics of Adidas Copa soccer cleats and the comfort. This is one of the most comfortable leather soccer shoes. There’s also plenty of stretch for wider feet. The bad news is that others offer the same benefits for a better price. Best Soccer Cleats for Midfielders Nike Phantom GX 2 Elite ‘A step up in class from the already-brilliant previous Phantoms.’ Fit: Runs long Playing surface options: Firm ground, artificial grass Pros: Gripknit enhances ball control, touch and passing Bladed outsole offers superior pivoting Generous fit Out-of-the-box comfort Eye-catching design Cons: Runs long More responsive cleats available The first bonus point for the Nike Phantom GX 2 Elite is comfort. Straight from the box, these feel great. The second selling point, as a midfield maestro, is the Gripknit technology. It actually works! If I had to criticize Nike, I’d say that the fit is a bit off. Unless you’ve got wide feet, you may struggle. This is undoubtedly one of the best Nike Phantom soccer cleats on the market though. Nike have managed to enhance what was already a hugely impressive shoe. Adidas Predator Elite 2 Laceless Soccer Cleats ‘It has a host of famous fans, but is the Adidas Predator Elite worthy of the hype? The jury’s still out.’ Fit: True to size Playing surface options: Firm ground, artificial turf, soft ground Pros: Laced, laceless and foldover tongue options Strikeskin technology enhances grip, pass accuracy and touch precision Impressive Hybridtouch 2.0 synthetic upper Primeknit material moulds to the foot for optimum comfort Classic Predator styling Cons: Break-in time required Not suited to wide feet Price difference between versions is steep Adidas Predator soccer cleats are the shoes all the stars wear and every kid wants to see under the tree at Christmas. There’s always hype around a new launch. In my view, the Elite is worthy of the plaudits, but there are some negatives. Most of the good points revolve around control, precision touch, and enhanced accuracy and grip. The aesthetics are, as always, on point. The bad bit is the fit and the level of comfort, especially if you’re in the wide foot camp. If you’re looking for instant comfort, you’ll be disappointed. If you endure the break-in period, however, you won’t regret jumping on the Predator bandwagon. Best Soccer Cleats for Strikers Nike Mercurial Superfly 10 Elite ‘If speed is of the essence, the Superfly 10 Elite is the soccer shoe for you.’ Fit: Runs small Playing surface options: Firm ground, artificial grass, soft/wet ground Pros: Super lightweight for optimum speed Responsive outsole Out-of-the-box comfort Precision control thanks to Gripknit technology Super-thin upper for speed and comfort Cons: Limited protection Not ideal for wide feet Lockdown is not as secure as others How do you improve a soccer shoe that seems to already have it all? The answer? Innovative tech that increases speed and agility and maximizes control and comfort. I love the look and feel of these boots. Fresh from the box, they’re as comfortable as running shoes. A mention also has to go to the Nike Mercurial Superfly 10 Elite’s responsiveness. It’s a cut above. Now, some negatives. The fit isn’t ideal for wide feet, although sizing up offers a solution. If protection is key, Nike Mercurial soccer cleats aren’t the best choice. Adidas F50 Elite ‘Test your speed, change direction rapidly and keep control with the Adidas F50 Elite.’ Fit: Runs long Playing surface options: Firm ground, natural grass Pros: Very lightweight Designed for maximum stability and control at speed Enhanced lockdown Flexible, lightweight tunnel tongue Conical soleplate studs for safe, efficient rotation Cons: Runs slightly long and narrow The Adidas F50 Elite is back with a bang. Not only is it a great-looking soccer shoe, but it checks a lot of my boxes. It’s as light as a feather, it feels more comfortable than its predecessors and it keeps the ball stuck like glue when dribbling at pace. There are so many things to love about Adidas F50 soccer cleats, but this version isn’t a bona fide standout. Is it worth your money? It’s a tough call. For full-on speed and aggressive gameplay, you may be better looking elsewhere. Best Soccer Cleats for Goalkeepers Puma Future 8 Ultimate ‘Designed for agility and control, the perfect purchase for shot-stoppers.’ Fit: Runs long Playing surface options: Firm ground Pros: FLEXGILITY outsole for maximum agility High-density mesh for enhanced ball control Laced and laceless Upper contains 20% recycled materials Fuzionfit cushioned, customized fit Cons: Not for artificial surfaces Difficult sizing There are many reasons why I love Puma Future 8 Ultimate soccer cleats. First, the lightweight feel of the shoe. It’s comfortable from the outset. Second, the ease of controlling the ball. If you’re a goalkeeper, this is your bread and butter. With this soccer shoe, there’s a much lower risk of embarrassing slips and fatal blunders. Also, shout out to Puma for using recycled materials. On the flip side, sizing can be difficult. There are also better options out there for artificial surfaces, but this is another impressive offering from Puma Future soccer cleats. Nike Mercurial Vapor 16 Pro ‘Speed, comfort, control and grip: Elevate your game in an instant with these soccer cleats.’ Fit: Runs narrow Playing surface options: Firm ground, turf Pros: Super lightweight Flyknit upper Engineered for speed, grip and control Cascading studs enhance traction Competitive price Cons: Runs narrow What I love about the Nike Mercurial Vapor 16 Pro is the blend of benefits. Who thought you could have it all in one shoe? It’s consistently brilliant across speed, control, traction, comfort, and feel. It’s also an attractive price point compared to some rivals. The downsides are the fit, which runs narrow, and the speed. There are Nike Mercurial soccer cleats out there that are better for flat-out speed. Best Soccer Cleats for Wingers Puma Ultra 5 Ultimate ‘Fast, explosive, exciting: Buckle up!’ Fit: Runs long Playing surface options: Firm ground, natural grass Pros: FastTrax studs for enhanced traction Speedsystem carbon outsole for rapid acceleration Superior support and agility Super lightweight Cons: Runs long The Puma Ultra 5 Ultimate has much to offer. Lightning fast, it’s engineered for speed, agility and showing off skills at pace, but it also feels secure, comfortable and stable. Easy to wear from the box, I loved the soft grip of the upper. If there’s a negative, it’s in the sizing and fit. If you’re lucky enough to fit in with the Puma Future soccer cleats range, brilliant, but if you’ve got wide feet or you’re between sizes, you might struggle. New Balance Furon V8 Elite ‘All the best bits of the Furon family with impressive upgrades.’ Fit: True to size Playing surface options: Firm ground, artificial grass Pros: Engineered for speed Cheaper than other boots in the same category Hypoknit upper for accuracy, finesse and control T-shaped studs for quick, stable changes of direction Off-center lacing gives a truer strike Cons: Lockdown could be better What’s brilliant about the New Balance Furon V8 Elite? The highlights for me are speed, control and striking the ball cleanly. These are narrower than some of the New Balance boots, but they offer stability and a comfortable fit if you find the right size. What I didn’t rate was the style, but that’s only because there are more striking soccer shoes out there. Otherwise, there’s a lot to like about New Balance Furon soccer cleats. Best Soccer Cleats for Kids Adidas Predator Elite Kids ‘All the style and flair of the Adidas Predator range in smaller sizes.’ Fit: True to size Playing surface options: Firm ground Pros: Distinctive Predator styling Enhanced traction on natural grass Easy step-in Adaptable, molded fit Targeted strike zones for grip and clean, accurate shots Cons: Not suited to different terrains The junior versions of Adidas Predator soccer cleats offer many of the same advantages as adult shoes: The grip is great, ball control is superior and the boot molds to your feet. For ambitious youngsters, these are brilliant boots. If there’s a negative, it’s that Adidas Predator Elite kids soccer shoes don’t excel in offering multi-surface versatility. Adidas F50 Elite Kids ‘Engineered for speed, agility and close control at pace.’ Fit: True to size Playing surface options: Firm ground Pros: Designed for maximum speed and ball control on the move Sprintplate 360 tech drives acceleration Superior lockdown and comfort Cons: Limited protection Engineered for speed, I love the feel and weight of these Adidas F50 Elite kids soccer cleats. Based on the success and innovation of the adult range of Adidas F50 soccer cleats, these shoes deliver fast acceleration while providing security and seamless ball control. If protection is your priority for kids’ soccer boots, there are better options around. Best Soccer Cleats for Wide Feet New Balance Tekela V4 Pro Low Laced ‘Stretch and support combined with touch, precision and control.’ Fit: Suitable for wide feet Playing surface options: Firm ground Pros: Stretch and support for wider feet Laced and laceless styles Soft, flexible Hypoknit upper 3D molded Fuel Cell insole for superior comfort Low profile Cons: Suited to firm ground- no AG model Sizing may not suit everyone New Balance is making strides in the soccer shoe world, taking on the stalwarts. The New Balance Tekela V4 Pro Low Laced shoe impressed me more than I expected. There’s a raft of positives, mainly for the fit and instant comfort, but the price point is also competitive. New Balance Tekela soccer cleats boast a starry client base and the hype is justified. If you’re willing to stray from your usual brands, this could be the shoe for you, especially if you’ve got wider feet. My only grumble is that there’s no AG version. Mizuno Morelia 2 Made in Japan ‘Enduring quality, durability and style.’ Fit: True to size Playing surface options: Firm ground Pros: Timeless style Durability Remarkable softness and comfort for leather boots High-quality materials Cons: Price Retro style may not appeal to everyone Mizuno Morelia 2 Made in Japan throws a spanner in the works when comparing and contrasting ultra-modern soccer shoes. This is not a new boot, it features retro styling and it’s leather. Despite all these old-school quirks, it’s remarkably light, comfortable and luxurious. The quality of the materials is the key. I’m a fan of the look of Mizuno Morelia soccer cleats, but in this day and age, vintage, classic aesthetics are not for everyone. The price is another drawback at over $279. Best Soccer Cleats for Flat Feet Adidas Copa Icon 2 ‘An all-rounder that offers additional benefits for players with flat feet.’ Fit: Regular Playing surface options: Firm ground Pros: Classic design Regular fit Specialist outsole for grip, control and comfort on firm ground Premium leather Cons: More basic than other models A classic style fresh from the Adidas Copa soccer cleats range that offers enhanced comfort and control, the Adidas Copa Icon 2 is an all-rounder. I think of this boot as a Jack of all trades. It’s functional, comfortable and secure, it looks good, and it’s made using premium materials for durability. My concern for this boot in the ever-evolving market is that it doesn’t have the glitz and glamor of others. Best Soccer Cleats for Speed Nike Zoom Mercurial Superfly 9 Elite ‘Next-level ball control when you’re flying.’ Fit: True to size Playing surface options: Firm ground Pros: Designed for speed Super lightweight Flyknit tech for enhanced security Zoom Air unit for touch and grip Cons: Not suited to wide feet The Nike Zoom Superfly 9 Elite is a super lightweight shoe engineered for quick, controlled, creative play at speed. Debuting the Zoom Air unit, these soccer shoes offer superior touch, grip and security while allowing you to fly. I don’t have much to say when it comes to downsides. If speed is your priority, it’s hard to beat Nike Mercurial soccer cleats, especially at this price. Mizuno Morelia Neo IV Beta Elite ‘Built for speed with the finest lightweight K-leather.’ Fit: Runs narrow Playing surface options: Firm ground Pros: Premium K-leather Finest, lightweight leather in the Mizuno collection Luxurious feel Molded fit Enhanced flexibility, agility and grip Cons: Not suited to wide feet Mizuno is synonymous with quality, innovation and classic style that never dates. The Mizuno Morelia Neo IV Beta Elite doesn’t disappoint. Like other Mizuno Morelia soccer cleats, the quality is unrivaled. It felt luxurious but with an edge. Style, speed, comfort and grip: this soccer shoe has it all. The one thing I’m not a fan of is the fit. Break-in time is recommended. You might want to look elsewhere if you have wide feet. Best Football Boots for Every Position
Read more